Duality between Addition and Removal - A Tool for Studying Change in Argumentation
نویسندگان
چکیده
In this paper, we address a new problem in the field of argumentation theory: the link between two different change operations, namely addition and removal of an argument. We define two concepts of duality reflecting this link. They are used to propose new results about an operation from existing results concerning its dual operation. Finally, the propositions that are obtained are studied for characterizing the change operations.
منابع مشابه
Characterizing change in abstract argu- mentation systems
An argumentation system can undergo changes (addition/removal of arguments/interactions). At an abstract level, we propose a typology to classify the different properties describing a change operation. This typology reflects the evolution of three features: • the set of extensions in Dung’s sense (e.g., the set of extensions is empty before the change and not empty after the change), • the sets...
متن کامل(Economic and Social Duality in Iran (Using Fuzzy Topsis Decision-making
One of the planners and policy-makers’ aims on the one hand is optimum allocating and distributing of credits and facilities among regions and on the other hand is providing and compiling a suitable model aiming at achieving economic and social equity as well as creating reasonable and real economic growth. Paying attention to the balanced regional development, decreasing regional and district ...
متن کاملChange in Abstract Bipolar Argumentation Systems
An argumentation system can undergo changes (addition or removal of arguments/interactions), particularly in multiagent systems. In this paper, we are interested in dynamics of abstract bipolar argumentation systems, i.e. argumentation systems using two kinds of interaction: attacks and supports. We propose change characterizations that use and extend previous results defined in the case of Dun...
متن کاملStudying the relationship between surgeons' mental workload and their productivity: validating the "Surgeon-TLX" tool in Iranian surgeons.
Background and Objectives: The importance of surgical jobs and their high workload is known to many researchers. Until now, various studies have used the NASA TLX for measuring the workload of surgeons. The present study seeks to investigate the relationship between the mental workload of surgeons and their productivity through the validation of specialized tools for this job in Iranian culture...
متن کاملOn duality of modular G-Riesz bases and G-Riesz bases in Hilbert C*-modules
In this paper, we investigate duality of modular g-Riesz bases and g-Riesz bases in Hilbert C*-modules. First we give some characterization of g-Riesz bases in Hilbert C*-modules, by using properties of operator theory. Next, we characterize the duals of a given g-Riesz basis in Hilbert C*-module. In addition, we obtain sufficient and necessary condition for a dual of a g-Riesz basis to be agai...
متن کامل